1. Rev. Abijiah Sherwood 1843 – 1852
2. Rev. G. M. Stone 1852 – 1853
3. Rev. D. P. Maryott 1853 – 1854
4. Rev. Abijiah Sherwood 1854 – 1860
5. Rev. N. L. Reynolds 1860 – 1866
6. Rev. G. P. Watrous 1866 – 1867
7. Rev. J. W. Henry 1867 – 1868
8. Rev. G. P. Watrous 1868 – 1873
9. Rev. George M. Richter 1873 – 1874
10. Rev. J. E. Bell 1874 – 1876
11. Rev. H. Bray 1876 – 1878
12. Rev. George M. Richter 1878 – 1881
13. Rev. Samuel Early 1881 – 1885
14. Rev. A. W. Hodder 1885 – 1886
15. Rev. Frank H. Cooper 1886 – 1892
16. Rev. H. S. Quillen 1892 – 1893
17. Rev. Charles DeWoodey 1893 – 1894

18. Rev. F. W. Reynolds 1894 – 1897
19. Rev. L. M. Gates 1897 – 1904
20. Rev. Arthur H. Simpson 1904 – 1907
21. Rev. R. M. Hunsicker 1907 – 1912
22. Rev. Frank E. Eden 1912 – 1918
23. Rev. Norman J. Mecklem 1918 – 1921
24. Rev. David J. Griffiths 1921 – 1961
25. Rev. Earl Sires 1961 – 1966
26. Rev. Wesley Fisher 1966 – 1969
27. Rev. Benjamin E. Nevin 1970 – 1994
28. Rev. Peter Hill (Int. Pastor) Jul 1994 – Jul 1995
29. Rev. Richard Anderson July 1995 – Feb. 1996
30. Rev. Deb Casey (Int. Pastor) Feb. 1996 – Jan.1997
31. Rev. Dr. John C. Whitfield Jan. 1997 – Dec. 2004
32. Rev. Charles Mercer (Int. Pastor) Feb - Sept. 2005
33. Rev. Steven C. Case 2006 - present